| CITY 1 EVERTON 3 League Division 1 13th September 1958 attendance 35,437 scorers Ref L Peake |
City Fleet, Leivers, Sear, Barnes, Ewing, Warhurst, Fagan, Barlow, McAdams, Hayes, SambrookEverton O’Neill, Sanders, Bramwell, King, Jones, B Harris, J Harris, Collins, Hickson, Fielding, O’Hara